Let us be your First Choice for Sprotfishing Florida Keys in the Islamorada or Key Largo area!

Hello my name is Captain Larry Wren and I would like to invite you aboard our boat the “First Choice”. My one goal is… To provide you with a safe fun filled day, and to catch as many fish as possible!

My Florida Keys Charter Fishing Company offers Full Day, 3/4 Day & Half Day Islamorada fishing charters and Key Largo Fishing Charters in a relaxed, professional, fun-filled family atmosphere!

We offer the finest Sportfishing Florida Keys Trips that sail from Islamorada & Key Largo, Florida. The Florida Keys is known to many anglers as The Sportfishing Capital of The World. Islamorada fishing charters & Key Largo fishing charters are highly productive because of the warm waters that surround the Florida Keys. On our Florida Keys Sportfishing adventures we will take you Dolphin Fishing, Sailfish Fishing, Snapper Fishing, Grouper Fishing, Dorado Fishing, Tuna Fishing, Wahoo Fishing and Much More!


Islamorada Fishing Charters

I will take you charter fishing on my Custom Merritt Sportfishing boat powered with Twin Cummins Rail Diesel Engines, no diesel fumes. We have a very clean restroom!

  • Offering All Types of Florida Keys Sportfishing
  • Specializing In live Bait Fishing & Kite Fishing
  • Florida Keys Deep Sea Fishing & Inshore Fishing
  • Everything supplied for your trip (food and drinks are optional)
  • Half Day, 3/4 Day and Full Day Charters Available
  • Licensed Crew & Experienced Staff
  • We Take Up To 6 Passengers
  • We never keep your fish! All fish caught will be filleted and bagged for you to keep!

Day-Time Sword Fish Trips Available…

First Choice Florida Keys fishing Charters

Come see what it’s like fishing in The Keys with First Choice Charters…

July the Mahi are here in great numbers!
July web 1july web2

The magi have made there annual appearance with large numbers of schooling fish!
Islamorada fishing charters
florida keys fishing

florida keys fishingkey largo fishing charters

florida keys fishing charters

Islamorada fishing chartersflorida keys fishing charters



Sailfish are biting finally!florida keys fishingIslamorada fishing charterkey largo fishing

Florida Keys fishing Temperatures in the mid eighties and spring time fish starting to arrive! Some nice black fin tunas…

Happy New Years! The fishing has been great with seasonal species!  Sail fish are take the top spot around here!key largo fishingislamorada fishing charters

Florida keys fishing charters

islamorada fishing charters

Fishing remains strong with the warm sunny weather!

Key largo fishing ChartersIslamorada Fishing ChartersNovember brings the Sailfish along with some late season dolphin!

(305) 360-4900

Captain Larry Wren

First Choice Charters
Holiday Isle Resort and Marina
84001 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL 33036


Email Us

Your Name (required):

Your Email (required):

Your Phone Number:

Requested Dates:


TripAdvisor Reviews